Performer’s Perspective- Mahler 6, a decision
The Bridgewater Hall- Mahler in Manchester
The BBC Philharmonic will perform Mahler’s Sixth Symphony in A minor on the 27th of March at 7:30 under the direction of their Principal Conductor, Gianandrea Noseda. Also on the programme is the premiere of Edward Gregson’s “Dream Song.”
I am often asked to rank the Mahler symphonies.
Which one do you think is the greatest? Which is the hardest to conduct? Which is hardest to play? Which is a good one to start with if I am new to Mahler? Which one sells the most tickets?
Not surprisingly, my answers to all of these questions have varied over the years. They are all such compelling, challenging, rewarding, vexing works that working on or listening to any of them can quickly convince you that the piece on your desk is the greatest, the hardest, the most accessible, the most popular, the scariest or the most multi-faceted.
However, when asked for my “favourite” Mahler symphony over the years, my answer has been pretty consistent. It’s still a close contest and always has been. The late triptych of Das Lied von der Erde, the Ninth and the Tenth all mean a great deal to me- they are a profound source of comfort and solace and have been almost my entire life. The 2nd will always be special for many reasons because of its cathartic power and the special place it has held in my performing life. The 4th is simply perfection. The 8th, well, I just love it- I’m not too cool to love it, and I have no criticisms of it. On goes the list for all 11 works.
But, more or less without interruption, the 6th has always been my favourite of them all.


Recent Comments